Which RWL book the best?

[The Cow]

 I think Taggerung is awesome ::agrees::  ::agrees::  ::agrees::  

 They are all SOOOOOO good and touching, but Martin the Warrior is one of my favourites. I actually cried for Rose :( :(

[Brock]

 I vote Long Patrol, then would come Taggerung, Outcast of Redwall, Mossflower, Triss, Martin the Warrior, Legend of Luke, and then all the rest.

[The Lady Shael]

 Hm, that's a difficult question, I have many favorites, and I try not to put one above the rest.

My favorites list:

Mariel of Redwall
Taggerung
Marlfox
Salamandastron
Legend of Luke


[EDIT] *reads Trident's post* Aha, forgot Legend of Luke.

[Trident]

 Pearls of Lutra and Ledgend of Luke rock!

[TS/RULES!]

 The Long Patrol was a great book, the best in my opion.  I think MAttimeo is the worst, it drags on for far too long and it is just not a good book.  

[Brock]

 I've read Legend of Luke too many times and now it's kind of boring.  I'm
re-reading all the books in alphabetical order now and I'm reading Legend of Luke.  Started  reading it a few weeks ago and I'm only on chapter 6. :(  

[Bloodrath]

 The book of Mossflower is my favourite book. Great story and plot line, and keeps me interested. One of the original books, this displays one of Brian's best writing skills. Great book!

[Ruatine]

 Meh, I must have weird taste when it comes to the Redwall books.

My fav 5:

~Lord Brocktree (By far my most favorite!)
~Martin the Warrior
~Marlfox
~The Long Patrol
~Salamandastron

My most disliked out of all the books:

~Taggerung

Triss was okay, but definitely not his best work. Though I did enjoy the whole Riftguard Script thingie. I'm really looking forward to his book about Loamhedge. From what I've read about it, it seems like it's going to be really cool.

[Trident]

 Brian Jacques has only problem, is that everything has already happened before.  Triss is like a re-run of Pearls of Lutra, both involving some far off island.   Every book is basically the same thing; something comes to Redwall and tries to destroy it, and Redwall alwasy gets saved.  That's why I liked The Ledgend of Luke; it barely even involved Redwall, and it was an entirely different story than the rest.  

[Ashyra Nightwing]

 I really liked the Long Patrol. The battle was so well-written...

My top 5:
1. The Long Patrol
2. Marlfox
3. Mossflower
4. Martin the Warrior
5. Legend of Luke

[The Lady Shael]

 *nods* I've noticed there's a niche for certain characters in each book. For example, find the similarity between Fuffle, Arven, Skittles, etc. Find the similarity between Shadow, Bane, The Wraith, Farran the Poisoner, etc. Find the similarity between Skalrag, Migroo, Lugworm, etc. Find the similarity between Rose, Cornflower, Columbine, Song, etc. They all have their little spot to fill in.

[Aqualis]

 Once again, you try to make me chose one. And once again, I say no. Here are five of my favorites in no particular order.

Mariel of Redwall
The Long Patrol
Redwall
Salamandstron
The Legend of Luke

My least favorite is most likely The Outcast of Redwall. For me it was just completely boring. It seemed to have a broken story with no real direction. Everything seemed out of place.

I voted other.

[Pikepaw]

 I got to this topic before the evil me.  I love most of the Redwall books and can't pick just some out of them.  I must conquer the evil me!

[calria]

 I absolutely LOVE Martin the Warrior- it was the first Redwall book I ever read, read in an attempt to impress a crush I had, and I have to have worn out my copy and a couple of friends' copies re-reading it! Gotta love the pygmy shrews!