Kilk

Power of Mordor · April 05, 2003, 05:59:04 PM

In response to your poll answer should Ereptor step down I thought I should post this where everyone would read it. You said you proved a point that by breaking Ereptors defense once, anyone could do it. The point you proved to everyone in actuality was, you managed to take 100,000 acres from him, but because of this in the end he took all his acres back and 300k acres of yours back and killed you. Kilk... if you actually had good intentions #1. You would have disbanded after taking a portion of his land or #2. Secured the position of Rank 2 for Orcrist or Bloodfur or someone to follow you. Your decescion was rashly made, with no thought to the future. Please disagree with me if you can.

General Austin · April 05, 2003, 06:57:35 PM

I personally think he just wanted someone else to take the glory. He doesn't go on the forums much, anyways, so your argument has a small chance of getting anyhwere. May I ask who you are?

Badrang the Tyrant · April 05, 2003, 07:10:51 PM

Kilk knew that Ereptor would kill him. He also hoped that someone would come right after him and attack as soon as Ereptor wasted so many troops on him.

calria · April 06, 2003, 03:10:33 PM

I seriously take issue with anyone who would credit/discredit Kilk by accusing him of acting rashly. He's been one of the top players on this game for way too long to do anything stupid.

Power of Mordor · April 06, 2003, 04:09:29 PM

To calaria... So since in general he makes good decescions even though this one made no sense it was wise? So Kilk can do no wrong? Why wouldnt he have secured the spot of #2 for orcrist or someone? Or waited for alliance members to control the top 10 to attack Ereptor? Kilk made a bad move.

calria · April 06, 2003, 04:17:37 PM

Quote from: Power of MordorTo calaria... So since in general he makes good decescions even though this one made no sense it was wise? So Kilk can do no wrong? Why wouldnt he have secured the spot of #2 for orcrist or someone? Or waited for alliance members to control the top 10 to attack Ereptor? Kilk made a bad move.

#1: My name is Calria.
#2: "So, since, in general, he makes good decisions, even though this one makes no sense, he was wise?"
#3: "Why wouldn't he have secured the spot of #2 for Orcrist, or someone, or waited for alliance members to control the top 10 before attacking Ereptor?"
#4: Who are you to question Kilk (or me, for that matter), anyway? You can't even spell decently.

Power of Mordor · April 06, 2003, 04:22:26 PM

Does it matter who I am or what I said? You understood the points I was trying to get across, and I am sorry if my spelling offends you all that much. Still you have not responded.

calria · April 06, 2003, 04:29:28 PM

I have no answer for you.

You ask me to validate his actions, and yet supply me with no reason why I should.
You speak with the astuteness of an oldbie, and yet with the arrogance and chutzpah of a newbie fresh for the killing.

...reminds me of Beatles...
Pah!

Power of Mordor · April 06, 2003, 04:31:54 PM

Thats why the forum post was there Calria. I posted it for answers, if you have no answer or nothing to say., then why would you respond at all. Please do correct my grammar and then answer me.

calria · April 06, 2003, 04:37:55 PM

I'll skip on the grammar this time and go straight for the answer. Happy?

I answered in order to make the point that Kilk is intelligent enough of a player to do things for his own reasons- reasons other than rashness and a lack of judgement.
Kilk alone can answer definitively why he did what he did. I merely would like to point out that we should not automatically assume stupidity on his part. He's smarter than that... a lot smarter.

Power of Mordor · April 06, 2003, 04:40:07 PM

Interesting, well then we will have to hear his reasons. If your opinion is you have no opinion is it necescarry to start attacking me for grammar and ideas? You dont disagree with me for any reasons yet you call me arrogant.

calria · April 06, 2003, 04:51:14 PM

Josh?

Power of Mordor · April 06, 2003, 04:55:24 PM

Answer my questions. Calria no one really likes you jumping on them for no reasons whatsoever.

calria · April 06, 2003, 05:01:09 PM

I'm not jumping on your for "no reason whatsoever," Josh. I jumped on you because of the fact that you accused Kilk of, in effect, suiciding with no real gain involved for either himself or his cause. I believe that this is not the case, and that he had some real reason for doing this, which will be clarified once he is given the chance to speak for himself. We should not degrade him before he himself has had a chance to speak. That's my stance.

Oh, and by the way- welcome back.

Power of Mordor · April 06, 2003, 05:04:47 PM

#1. Dont tell me who I am. Why would I be Josh?

#2. I claim his attacks are suicidal and only made Ereptor stronger. You chose to disagree with no reason at all and call me arrogant.

#3. Why make a post that has absolutely no meaning? Your opinions are meaningless if you do not choose to back up what you say.